Ningalku Map Illa- The Maphunt
Published: 4 July, 2021 | 10 mins(s) read | Tags: #Maps #Data #Impact Stories
Table of contents:
നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല (Read as Ningalku Map Illa) is the hashtag I started on social media for flagging wrong maps of Kerala. This is the expanded form of my Twitter thread which features wrong maps of Kerala by various organisations.
License: This article is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license.
Recently social media was yelling about the usage of the wrong map of India by Twitter on their website. Well before the issue, I had started a hashtag campaign on the wrong maps published by the government and various other reputed organisations. The Hashtag was only limited to the Kerala Maps. Some people had put some effort in correcting the maps some might not have seen, some have ignored.
The goal of this campaign is not the blame or defame anyone, but to correct and educate everyone on the matter of maps. Hence as a geospatial person, I feel this is my duty to point out the mistakes and help people in correcting them.
Hashtag - #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല
Though I started the thread without a hashtag thing there won’t be a big number, soon I realised that all I saw was the tip of the iceberg. Hence going with the suggestion put forward by Jasbeer, my friend I adopted the hashtag #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല.
The hashtag means നിങ്ങൾക്ക് മാപ്പ് (മാപ്പ് = Map) ഇല്ല - You lack maps. It also has a Homonym meaning നിങ്ങൾക്ക് മാപ്പ് (മാപ്പ് = Pardon) ഇല്ല. It’s unforgivable.
The Common mistake
Most of the wrong maps were having the same mistake. So thought of sharing the reason with you all to be conscious on maps hereafter. Let me confess, I have also used the wrong map long back, and corrected it after knowing. Surprisingly the map we are using is 23 years old. (Update) Old Ernakulam district boundary is hatched in red and overlayed on new map.
In 1998, Kuttampuzha panchayat of Idukki district was transferred to Ernakulam district as part of the district boundary reorganisation. This caused the Idukki district to lose the status of the biggest district of the state and the title was transferred to the Palakkad district. This Panchayat is the reason for the mistake. Maps with mistakes include Kuttampuzha panchayat as part of the Idukki district and make the Ernakulam district smaller. So ideally the Ernakulam district’s boundary now extends to the eastern border of the state and share the boundary with Tamilnadu.
- The Hindu - English daily
After I pointed out the mistake they corrected the map on the very next day’s newspaper and this swift action is truly appreciable.
Thanks @the_hindu for correcting the #Kerala #map in the daily #CovidViz of the state. Yesterday I Tweeted on the usage of older map(https://t.co/RPLXXXe5Z1). Happy to see today's daily with corrected map.I believe this was made possible with the power of #OpenData @osm_in pic.twitter.com/3dMDgpukS4— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) February 6, 2021
- Datawapper - Data visualisation platform
Commenting on my above tweet, Naveen Francis pointed out that The Hindu make use of the data visualisation platform Datawapper and that could be the source of error. The Datawrapper team showed no hesitation in correcting the data, the process was faster.
Hi Naveen, Edurne here. Thanks for alerting us about this! We'll look into it right away.— Datawrapper (@Datawrapper) May 6, 2021
We consider that we could stop the Domino Effect by correcting the Datawrapper repo, since that is the source for many visualisations.
State Government Owned Sources
- COVID19 Dashboard by Kerala Government
The campaign thread was started with C-Dit maintained Kerala Government’s covid Dashboard.
This thread is to list the wrong #maps of #Kerala by various agencies&organisations.funniest fact is that even Govt agencies are on the list,who are the most reluctant people in case of sharing the #data. #opendata #geodata @opendatakerala— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) May 19, 2021
starting with https://t.co/sDAQoVZJLB pic.twitter.com/df9EpD3NUG
- Chief Minister’s Complaint Cell
Second one on the series was another C-Dit maintained websitecmo.kerala.gov.in.
https://t.co/jb227jydKe maintained by #cdit also uses wrong #kerala #map #opendata @naveenpf @manojkmohan @jaisuvyas @jinoytommanjaly pic.twitter.com/vKQEZGl3R3— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) May 19, 2021
- PWD Department
Map in the Public Works Department’s official website shows a wrong map of Kerala to visualise the division wise roads
Another #cdit maintained site is nxt in #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല series with wrong #Kerala #map. Kerala #PWD official site. Hope see the swift action in correcting #maps from CDIT as before. @riyasdyfi pic.twitter.com/RMYn0NujWY— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) June 15, 2021
Kerala Industrial Infrastructure Development Corporation holds the wrong map in their website’s park page
The map hunt continues #Kinfra website comes nxt in #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല series with wrong #Kerala #map. You can figure it out the mistake in all maps are the same.Also happy to see some have already corrected after pointing it out.— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) June 16, 2021
- Kerala Police
Though the map in Kerala police website is used as a symbolic graphic image and don’t indent to convey or visualise any data, both map and angle of representation are wrong. You cannot simply turn around maps and put them at any angle.
Next one in the #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല series is @TheKeralaPolice website maintained by State Crime Records Bureau. They too have a wrong map there. Hope our Police maman will change it to the correct one soon. (മാപ്പ് മാറ്റിയില്ലെങ്കിൽ മാമ്മനും മാപ്പില്ല) #Kerala #map pic.twitter.com/FqVNYpy9M6— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) June 6, 2021
Central Government Owned Sources
- India Meteorological Department
The Twitter handle of the India Meteorological Department(@Indiametdept) is constantly posting Districtwise and Stationwise nowcast data in the wrong map of Kerala. Their official website also holds the same wrong data.
@Indiametdept is using old #Kerala #map while @imd_trivandrum has an updated one.This again shows the need for #data sharing & is not happening even b/w same depts.Nxt in entry #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല (you won't be forgiven & in Malayalam its also read as you don't have the maps) pic.twitter.com/u9UdTx31nS— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) May 26, 2021
While their Meteorological Centre at Thiruvananthapuram posting from the Twitter handle posts the daily alters and updates on the right map. Surprisingly after the above tweet, I noticed that the Thiruvananthapuram centre Tweets with three varieties of Kerala maps. All three having rendered the Ernakulam District in three ways
#Kerala, we have 3 different #KeralaMap.This is serious negligence from the officials.@imd_trivandrum publishes 3 #maps with different dist boundaries.A clear evedence of what happens if there is a redundancy in #data and lack of standardization #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല #Pathetic pic.twitter.com/4QGsTVBQjN— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) July 6, 2021
This is serious negligence and nothing else. Surely deserves action on the concerned person and the department head.
- Know India
Don’t you see the irony in the name of the website? I don’t know how many people will be visiting this website. But the map published there on the Kerala page is the wrong one.
Next one on the list is @KNOWINDIAPORTAL its funny seeing #govt who need to decapitate correct data itself is lacking data. All I have to say is #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല (you won't be forgiven, in Malayalam its also read as you don't have the maps). #opendatahttps://t.co/s0MyOPn6vn pic.twitter.com/tuHm61DdZQ— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) May 24, 2021
State Election Commisionof Kerala
The permanent and independent body that ensures free and fair elections in the country published wrong maps of Kerala. It was quite a surprise to me that the authenticate source of maps we often refer to, itself publishing the wrong maps.
This is d funniest thing I have seen in this #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല #MapHunt.Wrong map & correct map published on d same page.@Ceokerala site has 2 right #maps,but the wrong #map is given priority.We used to keep #ElectionCommission Maps as base & now its alarming for us.#Kerala pic.twitter.com/rP9kBQusHN— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) June 18, 2021
The funniest fact is that the commission’s website has given the correct map of the particular district while the state map with the district boundaries is wrong. It was also found that there was another state map in the infographics with correct representation.
- Twenty Four News
The Malayalam news channel twenty four news will always stand out from other channels with their technological advancements bringing in the Augmented Reality, tele-transporting technologies first time in the Malayalam media. In the competition to present the news in the most appealing way to its viewers on the day in which new ministers of the state was declared they came up with AR graphics. The augmented reality was not the reality as per the map data.
This is from the #AR king in Malayalam media industry @24onlive also fails to represent #keralamap correctly@rsreekandannair pic.twitter.com/mxNus81Cna— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) May 19, 2021
- Asianet News
One of the oldest news channels of Malayalam, Asianet News on the same day failed to present the map correctly to its viewers. The same district wise minister’s names where represented on the wrong map of Kerala.
#asianetnews again the wrong #map @AsianetNewsML @vinuvjohn #media pic.twitter.com/XBRYKEq9a0— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) May 19, 2021
- The New Indian Express
The English daily used the wrong Kerala map in infographics they published on their website.
Here comes the next entry for #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല (You Don't have the map and can also read as you are not forgiven)@xpresskerala have #Kerala #map in the backdrop which is again having the same mistake in previous entries.@NewindianXpress— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) May 20, 2021
(LOL I'm enjoying this more to come) pic.twitter.com/AEiftS6S1g
- Mathrubhumi News Channel
Mathrubhumi News channel, owned by the mainstream Malayalam print house, who also publishes the second most widely read newspaper daily in Kerala in the same name uses the wrong map of Kerala in the title graphics of one of their news segment.
Seems like all the Malayalam News channels are using the same wrong #map of #Kerala.@mathrubhuminews uses the wrong #KeralaMap in the title of the news bulletin to become the next one in the #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല series.@mathrubhumi has a decent map why cant you use that? pic.twitter.com/XEmAbz6yZf— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) June 14, 2021
- Madhyamam Weekly
Madhyamam Weekly one of the popular Malayalam cultural magazines published by the same media house that had published India’s first international newspaper failed to print the correct map of Kerala in an article about the Krail project in their July 12 edition
Next entry in the #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല series is from the media group the @madhyamam weekly. The article on #krail has a wrong #map of #kerala. please correct the map next time we at @opendatakerala is maintaining a repo for this nowhttps://t.co/2pJyIqD0Ow pic.twitter.com/s2oKe3J9TX— ark Arjun (@arkarjun) July 6, 2021
C-Dit officials corrected the Map in the COVID dashboard the very next day itself. They also corrected the CMO website was also corrected in the coming day.
Thanks pic.twitter.com/zxkzHterPb— Abhi Krishnan R (@Abhi_Krishnan_R) May 19, 2021
Doing our part
It is unfortunate to see the negligence and complete lack of initiative from concerned authorities and various governments in maintaining updated, accurate maps of their respective states properly. But the community’s desire and enthusiasm to meet their own cartographic needs is not easily destroyed. We at Open Data Kerala were forced to package the district maps of Kerala under Open Database License (ODbL) which are retrieved from OpenStreepMap now available for the public to download for free all seeing these. The Kerala district layer released by Open Data Kerala
Open Data Kerala is also maintaining the repo for Local Self Government Body(LSGD) boundaries of Kerala and OpenStreetMap Kerala community is busy in making ward level map layers, expected to be completed soon.
The current ambiguity in map data is due to the following reasons ** Lack of updation ** Lack of data sharing ** Improper storage ** Redundancy in multiple repository ** Improper dissemination of information
Even after having an Open Data policy both by the central and state governments, it is not executed to its fullest potential. This ambiguity in map data is purely a case of a lack of proper execution of open data policy. The period which considered map data as classified data is no more applicable to the current era, where maps have become an inevitable tool for requirements ranging from complex scientific problems to daily life solutions like food delivery. The official government procedures currently being followed were created as per policies and laws that were made before technological advancements happened. Policies need to be revised to best address the current situation as well as accommodating room for the foreseeable future.
I won’t stop here. The thread will be discontinued, but will continue posting the maps in the Hashtag #നിങ്ങൾക്ക്മാപ്പ്ഇല്ല. I also request every one of you start posting the wrong maps and let the people be notified.
Any Comments on the article? Let me know @arkarjun.